British soldiers beating up iraqi trouble makers

Let's be honest, if the iraqi's had invaded england, we'd be petrol bombing their bases, and they'd be chasing us down for it and shooting us/beating us up.

It's war, let's not pretend it's all happy fluffy getting on with each other.

If they were trying to kill our troops, then ours have the right to defend themselves, and a beating is preferable to a shooting.

i've not seen the videos so im not even gonna pretend i know the situation or the stress and confusion...

BUT soldiers should be trained to hold their nerve in the face of severe provocation, if they all went off and battered people at the first signs of trouble then there would have been anarchy around the world for decades. these images are used as propoganda by elements in iraq and the occupying forces should be aware of what this looks like... iraq is in turmoil and a widescale civil war/uprising could erupt, do we want our troops in the middle of that?

however there are certainly times in conflict where making an example or dishing out a beating is necessary... as i havent seen the footage i hope for the soldiers involved this was one of those times.

Agreed

you fucking stupid cunt, the people you claim they where there to protect where trying to kill them and had been for two weeks before hand.

shut your stupid mouth and gho and think about something u know a little about like what records gaymen like to dance to.

"The facts" are common fucking knowledge for anyone who UNDERSTANDS the situation and the video....... the source is Andrew McNab ex-seas and currently emnployed as a security advsior) it was page 9 of the Sun yesterday

CUNT

If they had went out and shot rioters that had been trying to kill them you wouldnt have had a thing to say would u Jambon? cos they are the best troops in the world they controled the situation with no deaths..... CLASS OR WHAT

lol well if its page 9 of the sun...



violence is wrong in any circumstance

:laugh:

bollocks

your right

violence upon bollocks should be allowed in the right situation

i think smogs point is very interesting - Smog - watch the video WITHOUT sound and see what you think. Then watch it back with the commentary of the 'soldier' filming it.

it makes 2 very different versions.

if you knew the history of what happened that day and saw their reactions - maybe it in some ways explains the way they reacted - remember - this was taken 2 years ago - if this was happeneing everyday all over, i'm sure there'd be much more footage.

once again, the army being put on trial - i'm sure a lot worse has and will happen during tough times of conflict.

its not a Sun story made up by its jornos they are printing a direct transcript typed by Andy McNab.

Well done you also fall under the discription of.........


















STUPID CUNT

:blush:


@mos... has there been a link posted for the vid?

how the fuck am i lower class you cuntish prick

the army isnt being put on trial, just wait and see if any charges are brought......they wont be as they have done no wrong. The film maker is the only one to be arrested and he will probs get off with a telling off.

The only ppl with a problem are the uneducated public like this board but they dont count anyway

yeah violence in war is wrong isnt it

Pro Soldiers should not be viloent should they?

DAFT CUNT

http://www.channel4.com/news/special-reports/special-reports-storypage.jsp?id=1730

Works best in IE i think...

you are a horrid creature